As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, Colorado quarterback Shedeur Sanders has become a focal point of discussions, especially after an NFL scout reportedly compared him to former Cleveland Browns quarterback Johnny Manziel. This comparison has ignited debates among fans and analysts, given the contrasting trajectories of the two players.
Understanding the Comparison
Johnny Manziel, known as “Johnny Football,” gained national attention during his time at Texas A&M, winning the Heisman Trophy as a freshman. His dynamic playmaking ability and off-field antics made him a polarizing figure. However, his NFL career was short-lived, marred by inconsistent performances and personal issues.
Shedeur Sanders, on the other hand, has showcased a different profile. In the 2024 season, he completed 73.4% of his passes for 3,488 yards, 30 touchdowns, and seven interceptions, leading Colorado to an 8–3 record . His poise in the pocket and decision-making have drawn comparisons to quarterbacks like Joe Burrow, with Tennessee Titans head coach Brian Callahan noting similarities in their anticipation and accuracy .
Diverse Scouting Opinions
The comparison to Manziel is just one of several made by scouts evaluating Sanders. Some see parallels to Geno Smith, citing his polished passing in a wide-open college offense . Others have likened him to Tyrod Taylor, emphasizing his mobility and game management skills.
However, concerns remain. Sanders was sacked 52 times in the 2023 season, highlighting issues with holding onto the ball too long and a lack of urgency in evading defenders . These aspects of his game will need refinement at the professional level.
Public Reaction and Draft Implications
The Manziel comparison has sparked varied reactions. Some argue that Sanders’ disciplined approach and leadership qualities set him apart from Manziel’s tumultuous career. Others caution that any quarterback entering the NFL faces immense pressure and scrutiny, making comparisons inevitable.
As the draft nears, teams are weighing these evaluations carefully. While some insiders suggest that teams like the Cleveland Browns and New York Giants may pass on Sanders , others believe his skill set and pedigree—being the son of Hall of Famer Deion Sanders—make him a compelling prospect.
Conclusion
Comparisons between draft prospects and former players are common, serving as reference points for teams and fans alike. While the Shedeur Sanders–Johnny Manziel comparison has generated buzz, it’s essential to assess Sanders on his own merits. His collegiate achievements and potential suggest a promising future, provided he continues to develop and adapt to the professional game’s demands.
